Taste-matched follow-ups

Shows like Carrie

Use this page for more school bullying horror, maternal domination, and slow-building dread without retreading the same show.

  • psychological cruelty
  • maternal control
  • high school bullying
  • violent eruption
Carrie poster

6 shows to try next

Closest matches first, then broader nearby picks.

  1. Fugue State 1986 poster

    Closest match

    Netflix · Dec 4, 2025

    Fugue State 1986

    Why this fits: Fugue State 1986 delivers the same slow, suffocating build toward one catastrophic moment, where psychological pressure turns into something irreversible. Carrie’s high school cruelty and domineering family control echo in the way characters crack under isolation, then pay for it in brutal, final violence.

    • slow burn
    • psychological pressure
    More shows like Fugue State 1986
  2. If Wishes Could Kill poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Apr 24, 2026

    If Wishes Could Kill

    IMDb 7.3

    Why this fits: If Wishes Could Kill keeps the dread tight and immediate, with a countdown feel that makes every choice feel dangerous. Carrie’s bullying and maternal domination create the same kind of trapped, escalating pressure, and the horror lands through betrayal inside a close friend group rather than open-ended menace.

    • death warnings
    • high school friends
    More shows like If Wishes Could Kill
  3. Wild Cherry poster

    Direct match

    Paramount Plus · Jun 24, 2026

    Wild Cherry

    IMDb 5.6

    Why this fits: Wild Cherry brings the same uncomfortable focus on how private cruelty turns public fast, with humiliation doing real damage. Carrie’s schoolyard bullying and family control match the elite-school scandal pressure, where secrets and social exposure grind characters down until the fallout gets ugly and fast.

    • private school
    • best friends
    More shows like Wild Cherry
  4. Dear Killer Nannies: Criado por sicarios poster

    Deeper cut

    Hulu · Apr 1, 2026

    Dear Killer Nannies: Criado por sicarios

    IMDb 6.2
    Why this fits

    Carrie leans hard into slow-building dread and psychological cruelty inside a family where power turns vicious. Dear Killer Nannies: Criado por sicarios keeps that domestic danger in a confessional, child-centered crime memoir, but it trades horror’s catastrophic rage release for a more period, privilege-gone-wrong slow collapse.

    • childhood crime memoir
    • domestic danger
    • slow-burn revelation
    More shows like Dear Killer Nannies: Criado por sicarios
  5. The Terror: Devil in Silver poster

    Deeper cut

    AMC · May 7, 2026

    The Terror: Devil in Silver

    Why this fits

    Carrie’s school bullying horror and maternal domination land as psychological pressure that keeps tightening until something breaks. The Terror: Devil in Silver goes for psychiatric confinement and wrongful imprisonment, with bureaucratic cruelty and unreliable authority doing the harm, so the danger feels more procedural and institutional than family-conflict horror.

    More shows like The Terror: Devil in Silver
  6. Not a Stranger poster

    Deeper cut

    Netflix · Sep 17, 2026

    Not a Stranger

    Why this fits

    Carrie builds family conflict horror through slow, intimate psychological cruelty that escalates into catastrophic rage release. Not a Stranger shifts to a drama-thriller where the pressure comes from personal proximity and what you learn about someone, so the dread is less about school bullying and more about uncovering danger close to home.

Need another angle?

Search the archive for more like this

If these picks still leave you wanting more, describe the tone, tension, or structure you want next.