Taste-matched follow-ups

Shows like Crap Happens

Use this page for more grief-tinged comedy, surprise parenthood, and father son comedy without retreading the same show.

  • teenage son
  • awkward parenting
  • personal ambition
  • messy homecoming
Start with Shrinking6 reasoned picks
Crap Happens poster

6 shows to try next

Closest matches first, then broader nearby picks.

  1. Shrinking poster

    Closest match

    AppleTV+ · Jan 28, 2026

    Shrinking

    IMDb 8.1

    Why this fits: Crap Happens and Shrinking find humor in people trying to keep family life together while grief keeps disrupting their plans. Toni’s awkward new responsibilities as a father sit alongside Shrinking’s blunt, badly timed honesty and the strain between a therapist and his daughter, giving both comedies warmth without smoothing over the mess.

    • therapist workplace
    • father-daughter bond
    More shows like Shrinking
  2. The Mothers of Penguins poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Oct 21, 2026

    The Mothers of Penguins

    IMDb 7.4

    Why this fits: Crap Happens and The Mothers of Penguins find comedy in parents trying to keep their own lives intact while family responsibilities keep interrupting. Toni’s awkward new bond with his teenage son brings warmth beneath the jokes, while a fighter’s bluntness clashes with polished school-parent rivalries and gradually gives way to protectiveness.

    • school parents
    • class clashes
    More shows like The Mothers of Penguins
  3. Son of a Donkey poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Oct 30, 2025

    Son of a Donkey

    IMDb 5.8

    Why this fits: Crap Happens and Son of a Donkey find warm comedy in family friction, with characters stumbling through responsibilities they never planned to take on. Toni’s awkward new life with his teenage son brings grief and music ambitions into the mix, while Son of a Donkey turns fines, scams, and small humiliations into a lighter path toward father-son reconciliation.

    • best friends
    • shared incompetence
    More shows like Son of a Donkey
  4. Settling poster

    Deeper cut

    Three · Aug 6, 2026

    Settling

    Why this fits

    Crap Happens turns overwhelmed new parenthood and family conflict into comedy; Settling brings that domestic awkwardness to adults negotiating a platonic marriage and reluctant romance. Its focus is less on parenting pressure and more on disillusionment and the uneasy boundaries of sharing a home.

    • awkward domestic comedy
    • reluctant romance
    • platonic marriage
    More shows like Settling
  5. Crutch poster

    Deeper cut

    Paramount Plus · Nov 3, 2026

    Crutch

    IMDb 4.9
    Why this fits

    Crap Happens finds comedy in father-son friction and the strain of becoming a parent; Crutch shifts that family conflict to a father and daughter navigating life under one roof. Expect generational clashes and boundary disputes rather than surprise parenthood or a music career.

    • family conflict
    • generational comedy
    • father daughter comedy
    More shows like Crutch
  6. Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage poster

    Deeper cut

    CBS · Oct 8, 2026

    Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage

    IMDb 7.1
    Why this fits

    Crap Happens makes overwhelmed new parenthood and family conflict its comic center; Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage follows young parents facing in-law complications and extended-family demands. It offers a warmer small-town family setting, with the pressure coming from a young marriage growing up fast.

    • young marriage comedy
    • early parenthood comedy
    • extended family comedy

Need another angle?

Search the archive for more like this

If these picks still leave you wanting more, describe the tone, tension, or structure you want next.