Taste-matched follow-ups
Use this page for more supernatural crime cases, mythology-powered investigations, and spirit medium teamwork without retreading the same show.
Closest matches first, then broader nearby picks.
Why this fits: School Spirits keeps the supernatural crime trio energy by centering a mystery that runs through a school purgatory, with the protagonist investigating her own disappearance. Agent from Above’s spirit-sight cases and guilt-driven mission feel close in how every clue carries personal danger, but this one is tighter, teen-leaning, and more whodunit than action.
Why this fits: Wednesday delivers dry, deadpan supernatural sleuthing inside one haunted high school, with monster-of-the-week cases feeding a bigger whodunit. Agent from Above’s ensemble of a spirit medium, an optimistic student, and a detective who can see spirits matches the team chemistry and escalating threats, while Wednesday stays colder, funnier, and more puzzle-forward than quest-driven.
Why this fits: The East Palace turns paranormal investigation into case-by-case problem solving, mixing ghost-slaying work with court intrigue in 1400s Korea. Agent from Above’s folk-belief rules and escalating demon-realm stakes carry over in the way supernatural logic stays consistent, but The East Palace is more historical, contained, and focused on procedural monster-hunting than modern urban danger.
Why this fits: Astrid et Raphaëlle scratches the same supernatural crime cases itch as Agent from Above, but it leans harder into case files and an unconventional detective duo. Expect neurodivergent lead energy and detective work that feels more grounded than demon realm mystery, with less mythology-powered investigation scale.
Why this fits: Will Trent brings the wounded detective and high-solve procedural focus you get from Agent from Above’s mythology-powered investigations, but it’s wrapped in wry casework comedy. The workplace rivalry and trauma-driven investigator angle adds dark-to-dry humor, while the supernatural stakes stay more human and procedural than demon realm mystery.
Why this fits: Black Torch offers a reluctant hero facing mononoke monsters, which lines up with Agent from Above’s spirit medium teamwork and deadly ensemble confrontations. The body fusion and spirit war elements push the action into more animated, mythic spectacle, trading grounded case files for stranger, more fantastical survival danger.
Need another angle?
If these picks still leave you wanting more, describe the tone, tension, or structure you want next.
