Taste-matched follow-ups

Shows like Tell Me Lies

Use this page for more toxic romance, romantic obsession, and manipulative relationships without retreading the same show.

  • toxic romance
  • infidelity
  • manipulation
  • dual timelines
Tell Me Lies poster

6 shows to try next

Closest matches first, then broader nearby picks.

  1. Little Disasters poster

    Closest match

    Paramount Plus · Dec 11, 2025

    Little Disasters

    IMDb 7.1

    Why this fits: Tell Me Lies makes damaged trust gripping by showing how private choices spread into the lives closest to a couple. Little Disasters brings that uneasy intimacy into a circle of friends, where an accusation involving a child strains marriages and family bonds; its colder domestic tension replaces romantic obsession with uncertainty over who can be trusted.

    • family conflict
    • marital strain
    More shows like Little Disasters
  2. Museum of Innocence poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Feb 13, 2026

    Museum of Innocence

    IMDb 7.2

    Why this fits: Tell Me Lies and Museum of Innocence both make romantic fixation compelling through small moments that accumulate into lasting damage. Lucy and Stephen’s turbulent college relationship gives way to a slower, more inward story of longing, shaped by class and the objects one man keeps tied to the woman he cannot forget.

    • obsessive romance
    • period drama
    More shows like Museum of Innocence
  3. Beef poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Apr 16, 2026

    Beef

    IMDb 8.0

    Why this fits: Tell Me Lies turns wounded intimacy into a slow spiral, while Beef makes personal conflict gripping through stubborn characters who keep making things worse. Stephen and Lucy’s betrayals unfold across years; Beef starts with a petty road incident and builds into darkly funny retaliation that damages both people’s lives.

    • revenge spiral
    • wounded pride
    More shows like Beef
  4. The Party poster

    Deeper cut

    ITVX · Oct 11, 2026

    The Party

    Why this fits

    Tell Me Lies turns manipulative relationships into slow-burn heartbreak; The Party offers another drama built around buried secrets and devoted loyalty. Its country-house mystery and police investigation shift the focus from romantic fallout to old secrets and political scandal.

    • country-house mystery
    • lifelong friendship
    • class-crossing bonds
    More shows like The Party
  5. Wild Cherry poster

    Deeper cut

    Paramount Plus · Jun 24, 2026

    Wild Cherry

    IMDb 5.6
    Why this fits

    The toxic romance and lasting fallout in Tell Me Lies may appeal if you want Wild Cherry’s fractured female friendships and elite-school scandal. The suspense here also draws on social media humiliation and mother-daughter conflict, making the pressure more public and family-centered.

    • elite school scandal
    • fractured female friendship
    • mother daughter conflict
    More shows like Wild Cherry
  6. Euphoria poster

    Deeper cut

    MAX · Apr 29, 2026

    Euphoria

    IMDb 8.2
    Why this fits

    Tell Me Lies makes romantic obsession and unreliable intimacy central, while Euphoria brings volatile friendships and desperate choices to its raw teen drama. Addiction struggles and family conflict broaden the focus beyond relationship fallout into the risks shaping young people’s lives.

    • raw teen drama
    • addiction struggles
    • teen identity journeys
    More shows like Euphoria

Need another angle?

Search the archive for more like this

If these picks still leave you wanting more, describe the tone, tension, or structure you want next.