Taste-matched follow-ups

Shows like Dexter: Resurrection

Start with the closest matches, then branch into broader nearby picks tuned to psychological dread, cat-and-mouse tension, and identity reckoning.

  • morally gray
  • cat and mouse
  • psychological dread
  • urban thriller
Dexter: Resurrection poster

6 shows to try next

Closest matches first, then broader nearby picks.

  1. Memory of a Killer poster

    Closest match

    FOX · Jan 25, 2026

    Memory of a Killer

    IMDb 6.9

    Why this fits: Memory of a Killer connects to Dexter: Resurrection through a morally compromised protagonist whose identity is eroding while he tries to keep control of a double life, turning every new threat into intimate psychological dread.

    • alzheimer's
    • double life
  2. Paradise poster

    Direct match

    Hulu · Feb 23, 2026

    Paradise

    IMDb 7.8

    Why this fits: Paradise matches Dexter: Resurrection with its morally strained protagonist trapped inside broken institutions, where duty and grief collide and the past keeps resurfacing as the mystery tightens into personal reckoning.

    • flashbacks
    • los angeles
  3. Detective Hole poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Mar 26, 2026

    Detective Hole

    IMDb 7.6

    Why this fits: Detective Hole feels like a tonal cousin to Dexter: Resurrection by pairing a psychologically fractured investigator with a dark, story-driven pursuit of truth, where obsession, ethical erosion, and betrayal make the chase feel both personal and inevitable.

    • betrayal
    • corrupt cops
  4. The Chestnut Man poster

    Deeper cut

    Netflix · May 7, 2026

    The Chestnut Man

    IMDb 7.6

    A nearby match from the broader catalog.

    • morally gray
    • cat and mouse
    • psychological dread
  5. Barrabrava poster

    Deeper cut

    Prime Video · May 22, 2026

    Barrabrava

    IMDb 7.6

    A nearby match from the broader catalog.

    • morally gray
    • cat and mouse
    • psychological dread
  6. Red Eye poster

    Deeper cut

    ITVX · Jan 1, 2026

    Red Eye

    IMDb 7.1

    A nearby match from the broader catalog.

    • morally gray
    • cat and mouse
    • psychological dread

Need another angle?

Search the archive for more like this

If these picks still leave you wanting more, describe the tone, tension, or structure you want next.