Taste-matched follow-ups

Shows like Every Year After

If you want more soulmate romance, first love nostalgia, and friends to lovers, begin with the strongest matches and keep going. Every pick is a recent premiere or a returning season.

  • love triangle
  • childhood friends
  • flashbacks
  • nostalgic romance
Every Year After poster

6 shows to try next

Closest matches first, then broader nearby picks.

  1. My Life with the Walter Boys poster

    Closest match

    Netflix · Aug 6, 2026

    My Life with the Walter Boys

    IMDb 7.0

    Why this fits: Every Year After and My Life with the Walter Boys make first love feel tangled up with family life, where old feelings follow characters into everyday moments. Noisy meals and shared rooms bring warmth to the romance, while a brothers’ love triangle adds the ache of choosing someone close to home.

    • blended family
    • small town
    More shows like My Life with the Walter Boys
  2. High Tides poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Apr 3, 2026

    High Tides

    IMDb 7.3

    Why this fits: Every Year After and High Tides capture the sweet ache of first love, with friendships and family ties shaping young people’s choices. Beach days and summer crushes give High Tides a brighter, more restless feel, while betrayal and private struggles bring sharper heartbreak to its close-knit circle.

    • summer romance
    • beach town
    More shows like High Tides
  3. Still Shining poster

    Direct match

    Netflix · Mar 6, 2026

    Still Shining

    IMDb 7.2

    Why this fits: Still Shining shares Every Year After’s tender focus on first love that lingers, with family bonds and memories shaping a heartfelt romance. Its Seoul setting and reunion after years apart give the story a quieter, more reflective feel, as grief and growing up sit alongside the hope of finding each other again.

    • second chances
    • family bonds
    More shows like Still Shining
  4. Another Self poster

    Deeper cut

    Netflix · Jun 24, 2026

    Another Self

    IMDb 7.2
    Why this fits

    Every Year After makes first love and family ties ache across the years; Another Self brings that emotional focus to old friends taking a seaside road trip and finding new beginnings. Its sunlit warmth and gentle conflicts offer a softer, more hopeful watch than a romance built around lingering what-ifs.

    • warm friendship drama
    • sunlit romance
    • comforting love stories
    More shows like Another Self
  5. Off Campus poster

    Deeper cut

    Prime Video · May 13, 2026

    Off Campus

    IMDb 8.2
    Why this fits

    The first-love longing in Every Year After can lead naturally to Off Campus, where a music student and hockey star navigate romantic tension amid loyal college friendships. The campus setting and sports banter make it livelier and more youthful, while the central couple keeps the story focused on love and growing up.

    • swoony romance
    • college love story
    • hockey romance
    More shows like Off Campus
  6. Outlander: Blood of My Blood poster

    Deeper cut

    STARZ · Sep 18, 2026

    Outlander: Blood of My Blood

    IMDb 8.1
    Why this fits

    Every Year After’s sweeping romance and family conflict find a grander scale in Outlander: Blood of My Blood, with courtships shaped by feuding clans and divided loyalties. This period saga adds wartime danger, rough-country journeys, and a time-travel mystery, making its romantic longing more adventurous and historically rooted.

    • sweeping historical romance
    • forbidden love
    • feuding families
    More shows like Outlander: Blood of My Blood

Need another angle?

Search the archive for more like this

If these picks still leave you wanting more, describe the tone, tension, or structure you want next.